Guest Stars Drew Fuller as Chris Perry Rebecca Balding as Elise Rothman Sandra Prosper as Sheila Morris Michael Gilden as Finnegan Danny Woodburn as Head Dwarf Brian Thompson as Cronus Eyal Podell as Roland Will Kempe as Demetrius Nick Kiriazis as Evan Lee Arenberg as Demon John Cothran, Jr. as Cecil Lisa Thornhill as Meta Co Starring Scout Taylor-Compton as Thistle Niki Botelho as Elf Woman Damani Roberts as Michael Morris Trey Alexander as Rick Channing Pourchot as Sara