When Piper gives up on finding Mr. Right, she becomes extremely overprotective of Wyatt. As a result, Phoebe and Paige become worried and as result, decide to create a potion to create the perfect guy and decide to give Piper "Mr. Right" as a birthday present, hoping to get her to remember how important love is. Meanwhile, Chris and Leo try to keep Wyatt safe from a demonic cult called "the Order" after they flip Wyatt's sense of morality.