Guest Stars James Read as Victor Bennett Jenya Lano as Inspector Sheridan Sandra Prosper as Sheila Morris Elizabeth Dennehy as Sandra Oded Fehr as Zankou Glenn Morshower as Agent Keyes Becki Newton as New Piper Danneel Ackles as New Paige Danielle Savre as New Phoebe Evan Parke as Kahn Jacqui Maxwell as Vampire Queen Co Starring Scout Taylor-Compton as Thistle Jake Dinwiddie as Fairy Dean Cudworth as Cop Justin Baldoni as Salko Stacy Solodkin as Female Demon #2 Laura McLauchlin as Female Demon #1 Agim Kaba as New Leo / Handsome Man