Guest Stars Jennifer Irwin as Creepy Carol Michael Rosenbaum as Dutch Nilbog Trevor Moore as Josh Armstrong Ted McGinley as Larry Garcia Co Starring Ali Wong as Ana Ng Carlease Burke as Brenda Heather Moiseve as Cherise Bonnie Burroughs as Mrs. Sparks Soledad St. Hilaire as Gloria Jessica Gonzales as Young Melanie Jett Cloud as 12 Year Old Cash