Guest Stars Ted McGinley as Randy Labayda Brooke D'Orsay as April McCarthur Jamie McShane as Roger Co Starring Liam James as Young Shawn Carlos McCullers, II as Young Gus Cam Cronin as Tim Nicole Fraissinet as Teacher Keith MacKechnie as Coroner Michael Tiernan as Spriggs Steve Maddock as Guard Anthony Dodd as Horn-Rimmed Guy