Guest Stars Aisha Tyler as Dr. Tara Elisabeth Lewis David Lim as CEO Kevin Bruner Eric Nenninger as James O'Neill Paolo Andino as Anthony Simmons Co Starring Dorcas Tejada as Female Reporter Matt Odachowski as Male Reporter Frederick Dawson as Curtis Price Kavi Ladnier as Elaine Simmons Jenna Willis as Amy Gibb Leslie Murphy as Detective Connie Lawlor Rick Steadman as Principal Brendan Burke Joseph Callari as Arthur Gibb Melissa Ciesla as M.E. Janet Foster Maverick Thompson as Young James