Guest Stars Kirsten Vangsness as Penelope Garcia Meredith Monroe as Haley Hotchner Dana Emberson as Unsub Roberto Sanchez as SWAT Leader Neal Jones as Karl Arnold Tony Todd as Eric Miller Bonita Friedericy as Dr. Rachel Howard Abraham Benrubi as Frank Fielding Allison Dunbar as Allison Crawford Dameon Clarke as Chris Crawford Emma Polhemus as Emily Crawford Alexandra Wyshak as Jackie Dunken Jon Barton as Military Technical Tactical Advisor Chaise Goris as Sarah Arnold Colton Shires as Sam Crawford Chane't Johnson as Barbara Raleigh Jacqueline Mazarella as Robin Dunken Sharrise Baker as Fay Arnold Leith Burke as Michael Kapp Warren Davis as Harry Dunken Zackary M. Fisher as Karl Arnold Jr.