Special Guest Stars David Sutcliffe as Christopher Hayden Sherilyn Fenn as Anna Nardini Guest Stars Liz Torres as Miss Patty Aris Alvarado as Caesar Vanessa Marano as April Nardini Devon Michaels as Bill Krysten Ritter as Lucy Adam Hendershott as A.K. Michelle Ongkingco as Olivia Rona Benson as Joni Amy Sloan as Sheila Uncredited Ashley Fink as Artsy Girl
