Guest Stars Creed Bratton as Creed Bratton Ed Helms as Andy Bernard Craig Robinson as Darryl Philbin Rashida Jones as Karen Filippelli Nancy Carell as Carol Stills Stephen Saux as Justin Spitzer Brittany Ishibashi as Cindy Kathrien Ahn as Amy Co Starring Ursula Burton as Hannah Smotridge-Barr Tom Chick as Gil Kulap Vilaysack as Nikki Annie Sertich as Justin's Date Chatree 'Chad' Yodvisotsak as The Chef