Guest Stars Walton Goggins as John Cooley James Remar as Tom Benton Bruce Davison as Father Davison Carmen Argenziano as Father Paul Silvano Roxanne Hart as Andrea Benton Co Starring David Mate as Young Man Michael Buonomo as Uniformed Officer David Sullivan as Patrick Cavanaugh Weston I. Nathanson as Priest #1 Pamala Tyson as Medical Examiner Sean Holt as Young Matthew Joanne Ryan as Marie Valentine Jaret Sacrey as Matthew Benton Danielle Lester as Young Prentiss Dana Cuomo as Valerie Cliff Berens as Priest #2 Ian Foster Woolf as Cab Driver Kelly Michaels as Morgue Technician