Guest Stars John O'Hurley as J. Peterman Patrick Warburton as David Puddy Wayne Wilderson as Walter Megan Cole as Peggy James Spader as Jason 'Stanky' Hanky Michael Fishman as Gregg Jack Hallett as Alan Kathleen McClellan as Melissa David Dunard as Leader Brian Levinson as Andy Eric Simonson as Friend Uncredited David Richardson as Hanky's Friend Randy Carter as Elaine's Co-worker