Guest Stars David Rees Snell as Detective Green Josh Braaten as Colby Daniel J. Travanti as Mr. Mullens Co Starring Shaun Russell as Prison Guard Marissa Skell as Shelly Cristen Irene as Anna Michael Spound as Sam DeLilly Nan McNamara as Mrs. Langley Mary Beth Evans as Candice DeLilly Megan Gallacher as Jenny DeLilly Ellie Gerber as Heather Langley Renato Powell as Jocelyn Sherman Michael Ketzner as Young Colby Josh Woodle as Michael Young Heather McClurg as Karen Bachner Mateus Ward as Lyle DeLilly Michael Lesly as Officer Mark Hutter as Mr. Langley