Guest Stars Isabella Hofmann as Carolyn Baker Rossi Heather Tom as Connie Mason Cook as Bobby Smith Annie Fitzgerald as Marlene Smith Patrick Stafford as George Kelling Co Starring Blake Bertrand as Young Unsub Rebecca Spicher as Shannon David L. King as Detective Woods Shevaun Cavanaugh Kastl as Kelsey Tanner Elisabeth Noone as Mrs. Crenshaw Brecken Lawrence as Timmy Tanner Doug Dezzani as Charles Tanner