Guest Stars Jayne Atkinson as FBI Section Chief Director Erin Strauss Sam Hennings as US Marshal John Tilghman Co Starring Troy Kotsur as John Myers Ray Mirabal as Mitch Gregory Matt Beck as Tyler Parker Jarrod Bailey as Teenage James Bianca D'Ambrosio as Kelly Tucker Brian Slaten as Danny Tucker Jessica Ires Morris as Julie Myers Julia Silverman as Dr. Janine Ainsworth Kayla Tabish as Girl at Rest Stop Meagan Campbell as Laura Tucker Tracy Fraim as Kevin Jenson Aidan Collins as Young James