Special Guest Stars Nathan Lane as Eddie Donaghy Guest Stars Katrina Bowden as Cerie Maulik Pancholy as Jonathan Lonny Ross as Josh Girard Jason Sudeikis as Floyd DeBarber Boris McGiver as Patrick Anna Chlumsky as Other Liz Molly Shannon as Katherine Catherine Brian Murray as Jack's Dad Siobhan Fallon as Patricia Co Starring Alice Kremelberg as Margaret Dan Bakkedahl as Angry Father Chris Hoch as Lewis John Mooney as Preacher Henry Boyle as Henry Kristen Sudeikis as Instructor Uncredited Takako Haywood as Accountant