Guest Stars Will Forte as Paul L'Astnamé Steve Buscemi as Lenny Wosniak Eric Ruffin as Young Tracy Hannibal Buress as Hannibal André Ward as Daryl Weenus Co Starring Sarah Schenkkan as Young Girl Don Stephenson as Man on Subway Katherine Puma as Woman on Subway Alvaro Paulino, Jr. as Mariachi Uncredited Ryan Redebaugh as Startled New Yorker