Guest Stars Gordon Clapp as Det. Greg Medavoy Sharon Lawrence as A.D.A Sylvia Costas Gail O'Grady as Donna Abandando Michael DeLuise as Andy Sipowicz Jr. Debrah Farentino as Robin Wirkus Daniel Benzali as James Sinclair, Esq. Charles Levin as A.D.A. Maury Abrams Dean Norris as Father Jerry Downey Louis Giambalvo as Dominic Bucci Dale Raoul as Polly Stanley Anderson as Professor John Goldman Chaka Forman as William T. "Billy" Martin Dennis Creaghan as Monsignor Doherty Michael Mantell as Steve White Co Starring Tom Caruso as Uniform Officer Rick Cicetti as E.S.U. Cop John Elsen as Cop Michael Ian Black as Joey Diaz Mario Cantone as Bidder #1 Tony Hoty as Auctioneer Greg Haberny as Jerry Greg Salata as Medical Examiner Danielle Kimberly Shuman as Jennifer Bucci Anibal Lleras as Bidder #2 Ted Brunetti as Bidder #3