Guest Stars Josh Zuckerman as Max Miller Justin Deeley as Austin Tallridge Cameron Goodman as Bree Yani Gellman as Diego Flores Robert Hoffman as Caleb Walsh Caitlin Thompson as Madison Stewart Nick Carter as Himself Co Starring Erik Valdez as Eric David Grant Wright as Monsignor Joseph Katrina Norman as Kiki Amaris Davidson as Miranda Uncredited Arielle Kebbel as Vanessa Shaw