Guest Stars Royce Johnson as Brett Mahoney Peter McRobbie as Father Paul Lantom Susan Varon as Josie Matt Gerald as Melvin Potter Pat Kiernan as News Anchor #1 Katt Masterson as Detective Sgt. Thompson Tony Curran as Finn Joshua Bitton as Rory Ryan Woodle as George Bach Mark David Watson as Rafe John Joseph Gallagher as Seamus Gordon Silva as Bartender Rod Knoll as Owner