Guest Stars Betty White as Catherine Piper Lou Beatty, Jr. as Judge Gordon Kolodny William Russ as Assistant D.A. Christopher Palmer John Thaddeus as Detective John Stephenson Kurt Fuller as Reverend Donald Diddum Lisa Kaminir as D.A. Valerie Murrow H. Richard Greene as Judge Harry Hingham Ryan Cutrona as Congressman Raymond Jacobs Michael Bryan French as Alex Naughton