Guest Stars Jonathan Kowalsky as Mike Cosmatopolis Rick Gomez as AUSA David Vasquez Justin Welborn as Carl Lennon Kaitlyn Dever as Loretta McCready Mel Fair as Deputy U.S. Marshal Nelson Dunlop Mary Steenburgen as Katherine Hale Sam Elliott as Avery Markham Ryan Dorsey as Earl Lennon Jeff Fahey as Zachariah Randolph Jonathan Tucker as Boon Chad Todhunter as Deputy Stiles Louis Herthum as Detective Willits Co Starring Robert Neary as County Cop #2 / Crosley Otto Krause as County Cop #1 / Birch David Wells as Doctor Josh Clark as Jailer Robert Mukes as Cell Mate