Special Guest Stars Ben Feldman as Fred Paula Abdul as Judge Paula Robert Irvine as Himself Guest Stars David Denman as Tony Nicastro Tyce Diorio as Choreographer Devon Gummersall as Ethan Paula Newsome as Wanda Williams Co Starring Gregory Alan Williams as Judge Warren Libby Jennifer Gatti as Bar Prosecutor Marc Gowan as Judge Elkins Todd Truley as Ins. Defense Attny Sydney Vaughn Furgess as Jackie Williams David Clyde Carr as Gus Melvoy