Special Guest Stars Ben Feldman as Fred Guest Stars Camille Guaty as Wendy Simon Matt Letscher as A.J. Fowler Barry Watson as Evan Robbins Jake Pavelka as Toby Co Starring Rhoda Griffis as Paula Dewey Vickie Eng as Judge Rita Mayson Clayton Landey as Judge Andrew Brody Robert Treveiler as Nathan Hart Scott Poythress as Russell Westenson Tisha French as Julie Cafferty Justin Smith as Charlie Taggart