Special Guest Stars Ben Feldman as Fred Guest Stars Jaime Ray Newman as Vanessa Hemmings Brooke D'Orsay as Deborah "Deb" Dobkins Natasha Henstridge as Claire Harrison Gail O'Grady as Mrs. Thomas Amelia Rose Blaire as Abbey Tildon Ziah Colon as Olivia Kari Coleman as Mrs. Tildon David Martyn Conley as Police Officer Lisa Arrindell Anderson as Thomas' Lawyer Co Starring Kathy Payne as Judge Nina Hodge Margo Moorer as Judge Donaldson Tony Vaughn as Judge Nolan Murphy Susan Williams as Patty Hemmings Jasmine Burke as Lily Aubrey Peeples as Madison Thomas Paul Ryden as Judge Byron Hemmings Will Haze as Simon Bell Charles Van Eman as D.A. Eric Brassard Peyton Lee as Bradley Monica Padman as Emma