Guest Stars Justin Deeley as Paul Gregory Alan Williams as Judge Warren Libby Kenny Alfonso as Joe Cummings Kwajalyn Brown as Judge Tara Flint Faith Prince as Elaine Bingum Tom Nowicki as Geoff Hensley Natalie Hall as Britney Nancy Grace as Herself Doug Savant as Jakob Yordy Peri Gilpin as Miss Ortiz Nico Evers-Swindell as Zack Trent Rebecca Mader as Mistress Robin Barrett Carnahan as Isaac Yordy Jon Michael Davis as Tripp Osgood Co Starring Jeffrey Karantza as Lawyer Melissa LeEllen as Contestant Mike Stoudt as Police Officer