Guest Stars Aidy Bryant as Alice Nick Di Paolo as Nick Rebecca Hall as Rachel Co Starring Liza Treyger as Melissa Zach Cherry as Young Hipster 1 Julio Torres as Young Hipster Peter Benson as Accountant Charles Techman as Very Very Old Man Stephen Wallem as Randall Tara Gadomski voices Anchor Person Jonathan Hadary as Bearded Man G. Keith Alexander voices Announcer Lena Einbinder as Hipster Paul Laudiero as Young Hipster 2