Guest Stars Andrea Anders as Rena Vining Matthew Morrison as Blaine Cleary Jenna Gavigan as Josie Biggs Aunjanue Ellis as Ivy Kirk Deborah Strang as Martha Biggs Julie Dretzin as Karen Griffiths Cornell Womack as Officer Bill Mallard William Langan as Chief Robaire Co Starring Bill Tangradi as Officer Ronald Karnofsky Martin Kildare as John Biggs Robert Dolan as Officer Arnold Owens Rob Kahn as Officer Chris Butler Michael Eric Strickland as Malcolm Tucci Nicole Dalton as Polly Turnage