Guest Stars Tessa Albertson as Caitlin Miller Dan Amboyer as Thad Steadman Kathy Najimy as Denise Heller Paul Fitzgerald as David Miller Josh Pais as Todd Heller Co Starring Fiona Robert as Emily Burns Paula Leggett Chase as Jackie Dunn Fabrizio Brienza as Waiter Tim Rogan as Tim Elise Kibler as Sierra Katie Hartman as Marta Beem Stefaniya Makarova as Human Rawbar Hannah Marie Corbin as Aerialist Bartender