Guest Stars Meg DeLacy as Nyla Emma Fassler as Laurel Lindsay Pearce as Rebecca Granger Haley Lu Richardson as Ellie Dennis Paula Jai Parker as Margarita Jean-Baptiste Brad Beyer as Paul Morrell Rebecca Metz as Donna Marie Julia Campbell as Pamela Granger Jerod Meagher as Doug McKewn Angeline Appel as Young Cynthia Molina Laura San Giacomo as Gina Laura Bell Bundy as Monica Matt Raimo as Mitch Ashton Moio as Ethan Jeffrey Stubblefield as Detective #1 Co Starring David Grant Wright as Detective Cantrell Harris as Policeman #1 Samuel Whitten as EMT