Guest Stars Ally Maki as Dawn Chris Zylka as Joey Donner Jolene Purdy as Mandella Xosha Roquemore as Baby Ryan Pinkston as Yearbook Photographer #2 Co Starring Allie Gonino as Michelle Tiffany Hines as Kaitlin Chelsea Ricketts as Britney Nadine Crocker as Lexie Greenberg Uncredited April Rose Krack as Lexie Greenblatt