Special Guest Stars A.J. Buckley as Adam Ross Guest Stars Robert Joy as Dr. Sid Hammerback Jacqueline Piñol as Rikki Sandoval Al Santos as Ollie Barnes Brad Rowe as Benjamin Sutor Matthew Yang King as Kim Wey Richard V. Licata as Lawrence Gelächter Co Starring Alice Rietveld as Sadie Kevitch Bryan Okes Fuller as Rev. John McKlowski Matt Wood as Justin Scott Nicole Pulliam as Bartender Mark Simich as Essex Palmer Skye Casey Arens as Sam Suzie Pollard as Lucy Scott Anthony Tavera as Ruben Sandoval Jason Hoisington as Young Benjamin Sutor Nathanael Theisen as Mario Galanti