Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Abigail Hawk as Det. Abigail Baker Gregory Jbara as DCPI Garrett Moore Sami Gayle as Nicole "Nicky" Reagan-Boyle Tony Terraciano as Jack Reagan Nicholas Turturro as Sgt. Anthony Renzulli Jennifer Restivo as Laura Taylor Michael Quinlan as Jim Beresford Charlie Tahan as Michael Keenan Chance Kelly as Dillon Carney Kate Hodge as Theresa Keenan Orlagh Cassidy as Anne Carter Frank Deal as Det. Alan Batali David Fierro as Super/Man David Bishins as Inspector Reid Ed Manley as Edward Keenan Co Starring Onika Day as EMT Cate Bottiglione as Renzulli's Wife Douglas J. Aguirre as Firing Range Officer Drew Bongianni as Lieutenant of 2-7 Ivette Dumeng as Young Mom