Guest Stars Harry Sutton Jr. as Reporter Robert Bill Irwin as Cardinal Brennan Heather Burns as Sister Mary Kevin Sebastian as Davey Lugo Danny McCarthy as Jerrie Demarest Frank Pando as Alex Fuentes Joshua Lagos as Perp Angel Rosa as Officer Montrose Leighton Bryan as Theresa, Reporter Joe White as Steve, Reporter Ashley Hill as Lucy Kandel Alice Ripley as Beverly Elvers Krystina S. Bailey as Charina Volney Stefflre as Todd Kowalchuck Madison Hatch as Kevin Monroe Jimmy Callahan as Detective Billy Kellin Zack Roberts as Brian Zinneman Tara Gadomski as Librarian Julian Gamble as Chief Ronnie Monroe Jason Cerbone as Detective Johnny Vassallo Kevin O'Donnell as Detective Mike Hofferman