Guest Stars Christine Ebersole as Ms. Newberg Meredith Hagner as Libby Ezra Miller as Tucker Bryant Ato Essandoh as Antoine Arden Myrin as Bonnie Day Olga Merediz as Esperanza Co Starring Tijuana Ricks as Carrie John C. Vennema as Dr. Adams Brian Berrebbi as Bruce Charles E. Gerber as Rabbi Patricia Hodges as Mira