Guest Stars James Franco as Sgt. Eddie Pepper Alison Rich as Detective Small Jon Hamm as McCormick Vicki Lewis as Anne Muffet Celia Finkelstein as Jane Dough Co Starring Bruno Amato as Neighbor Nakia Burrise as Mrs. Penelope Quigley David L. King as Mr. Neil Quigley Gwen Van Dam as Kindly Old Woman Lynette DuPree as Nurse Sharkey Harry Yi as Man Jonathan Palmer as Lawyer Gary Ballard as Small Bald Man Uncredited Alfred Molina as Dr. Edelweiss Matt Allmen as John Dough