Guest Stars Brandon Routh as Henry Phillips (1964) Chelcie Ross as Henry Phillips Kathleen Lloyd as Deborah Melissa Yvonne Lewis as Deborah (1964) Lisa Long as Helen Holtz (1964) Patrick MacManus as Daniel Holtz Barbara Tarbuck as Helen Holtz Michael Potter as Timmy O'Brien Carlo Michael Mancini as Anthony DeSica Paul Vincent O'Connor as Paul Nelson Bill Henderson as George 'Tinkerbell' Polk Co Starring Bruce McGregor as Clyde Jack Guzman as Bartender Patrick Gallo as Anthony Alicia Ziegler as Coed #1 Kelly Mantle as Drag Performer #2 Willam Belli as Drag Performer #1 Sean Neff as Teammate James Michael White as Howard Holtz (1964) Mark Nordike as George 'Tinkerbell' Polk (1964) Mimi Savage as Shelly Caleb Moody as Kenny O'Brien (1964)