Guest Stars Michael Cassidy as Zach Stevens Logan Marshall-Green as Trey Atwood Nikki Griffin as Jess Sathers Marguerite Moreau as Reed Carlson Co Starring Todd Bosley as Leon Carrie Ann Nagy as Clare Burnadean Jones as Woman in Plain Suit Robb Reesman as Maitre d' Matt Williamson as Bartender Uncredited Jesse Heiman as Winking Comic Book Nerd