Guest Stars John Milhiser as Steven Shaw Adam Hagenbuch as Eric Co Starring Lauren Elyse Buckley as Girsten Davida Williams as Tipper Freddie Martinez as Locker Geek Michael Chambers as Bachelor #3 Derek Daniel Du Chesne as Briefs Bachelor Eliot Schwartz as Bachelor #2 Nick Reiley as Bachelor #4 Margaret Slack as Hallway Chick Michael Espinoza as Boxer Bachelor David Lopez as Awkward Bachelor Fawn Bowen as Hallway Teacher Josh David as Football Guy Jeremey Penn as Commando Bachelor