Guest Stars Romi Dames as Traci van Horn Cody Linley as Jake Ryan Kat Graham as Allison Michael Cornacchia as Cupid Preacher Co Starring G. Hannelius as Tiffany Jill Basey as Older Woman Robert Ochoa as Boy #1 Brian Nolan as Host Buddy Handleson as Boy #2 Bailey Gossett as Bailey Emily Rossell as Mother