Guest Stars Nick Di Paolo as Nick Tom Noonan as Tom Reg E. Cathey as Harold Angus T. Jones as Horace the 9th Sofia Hublitz as Young Sylvia Amy Sedaris as Mara Colin Quinn as Jimmy Burt Young as Horace Sr. Nolan Lyons as Young Pete Jack Gore as Young Horace Co Starring Liza Treyger as Melissa Dov Davidoff as Dom Craig "muMs" Grant as Ricardo Michael Cyril Creighton as Mike Joanna Bradley as Joan George Wallace as George Adam Feingold as Mover Marina Franklin as Marina Deborah Offner as Abby Hwalan Shub as Morgan Uncredited David Blaine as Broke Customer