Guest Stars Michael J. Fox as Louis Canning Michael Cerveris as James Castro Ben Rappaport as Carey Zepps Anne Marsen as Jennifer Charlie Pollock as Detective Gifford Kia Goodwin as Sondra Jordana Spiro as Det. Jenna Villette Jason O'Mara as Damian Boyle Peter Ashton Wise as Ned Grant Sarah Wynter as Carol Mercer Reg Rogers as Asher Mercer Donna Murphy as Judge Alice Adelson Donovan Christie, Jr. as Anthony