Guest Stars Aaron Hill as Walter "Beaver" Boudreaux Derek Mio as Wade Matthews Eileen April Boylan as Betsy Jesse McCartney as Andy Co Starring Zack Lively as Heath Daniel Weaver as Ben Bennett Adam Crosby as Pickle Steffany Huckaby as Beth Nikki McKenzie as Holly Amy Gumenick as Reagan Cindy Chiu as Megan Christina Gutierrez as Pretty Rushee Uncredited Kristopher Hatfield as Jeremy