Special Guest Stars Marlo Thomas as Judge Mary Conway Clark Guest Stars Tamara Tunie as Dr. Melinda Warner, M.E. Peter Hermann as Counselor Trevor Langan Stephen Gregory as Dr. Kyle Beresford Jill Marie Lawrence as Attorney Cleo Conrad Alan Mozes as Reporter #3 Peter Riegert as Chauncey Zierko Katie McGee as Reporter #2 Philip Bosco as Judge Joseph P. Terhune Edward Bogdanowicz as ESU Madeleine Martin as April Hodges Jennifer Van Dyck as Ann Ostilow James Colby as Jeremy Ostilow Ryan Simpkins as Lisette Ostilow Cindy Williams as Nora Hodges William Franke as Denver Uniform Officer Nick Cubbler as Mitchell Edison Will Keenan as Billy Tripley Tim Ewing as Jonas Haase Susanna Guzman as Gladis Shane Haboucha as JJ Ostilow Sarah Jane Everman as Preppy Girl Kit Flanagan as Headmistress Jamie Proctor as Goth Girl Bill Hoag as Denver Detective Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration