Guest Stars Andy Buckley as David Wallace Michael Schur as Mose Matt L. Jones as Zeke Jackie Debatin as Elizabeth the Stripper Rachael Harris as Rachael Ed Begley Jr. as Erin's Biological Father Dakota Johnson as Dakota Joan Cusack as Erin's Biological Mother Devon Abner as Devon White Malcolm Barrett as Stanley's Replacement Spencer Daniels as Jakey the Stripper Bill Hader as Himself Seth Meyers as Himself Susanne Daniels as PBS Panel Moderator