Guest Stars Jolly Abraham as Doctor Delaney Williams as Counselor John Buchanan Aida Turturro as Judge Felicia Catano Laura Benanti as Maria Grazie Terry Serpico as Lieutenant Commander William Taverts Shiri Appleby as Ensign Amelia Albers John Getz as Admiral Vincent Albers Aaron Dean Eisenberg as Coast Guard Officer Matthew Wooten Will Janowitz as Coast Guard Officer Scott Graver Co Starring Alison Fernandez as Zara Amaro Lauren Noble as Carmen Joanne Baron as Counselor Diane Schwartz Johnny Wu as Police Officer Mills Phillip James Brannon as Petty Officer Zeke Lipitt Danielle Ferland as Tori Kate Levy as Cynthia Albers Hector Lincoln as Jesus Aldo Uribe as Ozzie C.E. Smith as Jury Foreman Keola Simpson as Male I.O. Kyle Nunn as Coast Guard Officer Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration