Guest Stars Rick Gomez as AUSA David Vasquez Jesse Luken as Jimmy Tolan Damon Herriman as Dewey Crowe Justin Welborn as Carl Lennon Michael Rapaport as Darryl Crowe Jr. Alicia Witt as Wendy Crowe Stephen Root as Judge Michael Reardon Danielle Panabaker as Penny Cole Jeannetta Arnette as Marsha Keyhoe Co Starring Jonathan Kowalsky as Mike Cosmatopolis Aubrey Wood as Mina / Abigail Kaitlin Ferrell as Teena Justin Huen as Alberto Ruiz Casey McCarthy as Gretchen Swift Heather Olt as Nikki Kareem Grimes as Reggie Daniel Moncada as Manolo Emiliano Torres as Manuel James Logan as Caleb Brenda Ballard as Old Lady Lisa Lynch as Genny