Special Guest Stars Wallace Langham as David Hodges Louise Lombard as Sofia Curtis Guest Stars Jon Wellner as Henry Andrews Archie Kao as Archie Johnson Liz Vassey as Wendy Simms Sheeri Rappaport as Mandy Webster Conor O'Farrell as Undersheriff McKeen Claire Coffee as Cindy Jansen Veronica Cartwright as Diane Ray Rachel Miner as Valerie Whitehall Ray Wise as Ernest Chase Daniel Roebuck as Frank Rosetti Amanda Seyfried as Lacey Finn Alex Skuby as Federal Agent Carmen Argenziano as Sylvano Fatelli Reagan Pasternak as Jill Shoemaker Dave Power as Bryce Gundy Rheagan Wallace as Mindy Faberge Johnathan McClain as Adam Chase Josie DiVincenzo as Waitress