Guest Stars Paul Dooley as Judge Philip Swackheim Robert Prosky as Father Patrick Martin Wayne Péré as Mitchell Orbis Anton Yelchin as Justin Langer Peter MacKenzie as D.A. Brunner Margaret Welsh as Kelly Langer John Wesley as Father Stanley Joley Amanda Carlin as Ms. Elder Tim Rhoze as Grant Danforth Co Starring John Sterling Carter as Judge C. Mantle Rebecca Klingler as Jury Foreperson Scott Richards as Jury Foreman