Guest Stars Ray Abruzzo as Detective Michael McGuire Teri Polo as Sarah Barker Andie MacDowell as Grace Chapman Sandy Grushow as Himself Leslie Moonves as Himself Co Starring Cheryl Carter as Reporter Sarah Ehret Karen Hensel as Juanita Marshall Crista Flanagan as Marcia Christopher Michael as FBI Agent Gus Lewis Terry Woodberry as FBI Agent Smoller Ben Mankiewicz as Anchor #6 Paul Keeley as AAG Mitchell Colt Liam Lagola as Bobby Donnell, Jr. Charlie Hulien as Dr. Raymond Hewitt Phillip Palmer as Anchor #1 Laney Fishera as Reporter #5 Brien Blakely as WYPR-13 Reporter Brady Schmidt Jerry Penacoli as Mitchell Roberts Ted Garcia as Reporter #3 Bibi Amos as Reporter #4