Guest Stars Michael Chernus as Kyle Elizabeth Reaser as Andi Co Starring Kiersey Clemons as Chase Rebecca Spence as Cheryl Lucas VonKampen as Allen Phil Ridarelli as Tom Marz Timms as Van Howard Suzanne Adent as Penny Tyla Abercrumbie as Shelby TJ Jagadowski as Bern Kristen Zolner as Party Guest Ali Barthwell as Halloween Store Clerk